Innovation in action book review
I hope everyone had a good weekend. I read “Innovation in action” over the weekend. A nice short easy to read book. I enjoyed it and recommend it.
I would describe this as a cookbook full of workshop technique recipes. Perhaps if I read the cover before jumping into the book I would have known that from the beginning :)
The book gives a structure for the phases of an innovation project in three stages of divergent and convergent thinking:
- Discovering then understanding phase, where the main theme is curiosity
- Creating then testing phase, where the main theme is creativity
- Resourcing then implementing phase, where the main theme is clarity
For each stage, it gives techniques you can use to discover or understand and so on. For example, how do you discover more about the problem(s) in the beginning (diverge) and how do you understand everything you discover about the options (converge).
The projects the book had in mind were almost all process improvement projects. It’s very easy to pick and choose what technique you want to use. Before each technique is explained, they first explain when you might want to use it.
Almost all the case studies in the book were completely AI generated which put me off. You get the idea from them though… The case studies were sent to the authors from other people who probably used AI to “tidy up” the case study, not AI generated by the authors themselves.
This sort of book is exactly what I was looking for. I had seen some similar techniques used at Allient NZ (especially from Topher), and I wanted a big list of all the possible techniques one can do at various stages of a project.
Some things that helped me appreciate this book:
- I had seen a few workshop techniques applied before. I had run some workshops previously but didn’t really have a framework for it or techniques to use. This book gave me both.
- I was familiar with double diamond design thinking which gave me a scaffold to understand this book
Some topics that stood out to me from the book:
Convergent and Divergent thinking.
Convergent thinking is easier and is what is taught in schools: you have a bunch of options and want to select one to move forwards with. Generating new ideas is a more difficult endeavour.
We lack divergent thinking at Allient NZ.
For myself, like most people convergent thinking was easier for me. I feel I have the spirit of divergent thinking: cultivate ideas and don’t kill them early, I just didn’t know how to do this divergent thinking especially in a group setting. This book helped me with that.
Have compassion, not empathy for people
The short version of their argument:
- Having empathy for people in hard situations is distressing to the empathiser… sexual assault victims for example.
- It’s easier to have empathy for people who are similar to us (culture, religion, ethnicity, …), which creates in-group-out-group biases
- Just saying you have empathy doesn’t mean you actually do have it. It seems arrogant to have a 1 hour conversation with someone then say you have empathy for them.
- Sometimes we assume we share feelings with someone but we are just projecting our own feelings onto them.
- Compassion is a positive caring concern, and brings with it a motivation to help alleviate the other person’s negative emotional state. Feeling for the person rather than with them
I was familiar with the dangers of empathy from reading Peter Singer a while ago, but it was interesting to see it mentioned in a different context here. Personally, I feel that empathy isn’t really something I choose to use, it’s something that just happens, so I can’t just turn off my empathy.
Something that just happens isn’t that scalable and is more difficult to teach. Compassion is a choice you can make, so maybe its a better way of doing things? Pondering this…
I might be experimenting on people here soon :)